Mock Trial Poses Real Challenges, But Pace Students Are Rising to Meet Them
At our first invitational of the year, the Pace Mock Trial team started the 2026–2027 season strong by breaking team records. The current President of Pace Mock Trial, Wren Shweiki ’28, who is studying criminal justice, earned a perfect score of 20 ranks, winning as an attorney on the Defence. Additionally, I won 17 rank outstanding witness awards on both the Plaintiff and the Defence. Two competitors ranking individually at our first invitational is a new record for the team. But that wasn’t where the record-breaking ended. Our team broke another overall record, taking four and a half ballots out of the available eight for all teams at our very first invitational of the year, competing against schools like Stevenson University, Rochester University, Seton Hall, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
“As someone who’s gotten individual awards before, it’s really nice to have my hard work recognized and to see how much I’ve grown as an attorney,” Shweiki commented, when asked about the feeling of receiving an individual award. Shweiki continued, however, by saying that the team awards are significantly more meaningful. “Receiving a team award means seeing everyone’s hard work pay off and knowing that we performed well,” Shweiki explained.
I wholeheartedly agree with Shweiki’s sentiment, both about the individual and team awards. While individual trophies are always a bonus, scoring well as a team is unequivocally more rewarding. I personally never expected to enjoy and value Mock Trial as much as I do, but in my third year as a competitor, I would be remiss to deny how it has strengthened me as a student and as a person. The research skills and overall dedication required to perform and perform well has broadened my ideas for my future career, even if I’m still not sure if I’ll actually end up becoming a full-fledged attorney.
Regardless, Mock Trial has made me a better reader. The theme-constructing elements that come with each case have sharpened my ability to see patterns in other forms of academic writing. The performance element has also improved my public speaking abilities, taking the strengths I learned from doing theater in High School to a more polished, professional level. The personal connections I have made through Mock Trial have also, in many ways, made my college experience what it is. I met two of my current closest friends through Mock Trial, and if I had never taken the leap and auditioned, I believe that I would not only be a worse student, but an overall worse friend and leader.
Get to Know Mock Trial
Mock Trial is an effective way to practice arguing the law for competitors who compete as attorneys and as witnesses. The simulated trials and preparation that goes into the competitions are both essential in understanding how the law is argued, and how to budget the time you have in order to make the best case. Pace Mock Trial is a collaborative process, with each piece of content being written and refined by several team members, in order to make it the best that it can possibly be.
The activity itself functions like most team sports, with two schools competing against one another. In each round of trial at a competition, two different schools will be playing both of the different sides of the case. Pace Mock Trial holds auditions for the school year in mid-September, and the goal is always to have enough competitors so that none of them have to take on the extra work of competing on both the plaintiff or prosecution and defense sides.
At an invitational or official competition, each round of trial lasts, at maximum, three hours. Each round is also scored by two or three judges. Each judge has a ballot scoring sheet, where they can score each of the 14 individual functions out of 10. The team that scores higher is the winner, and has “taken” that ballot.
The ultimate goal of Mock Trial is to score better than the other team. Every competition lasts for an entire weekend, with two rounds each day. Each team will be randomly assigned either the plaintiff or prosecution or the defense in the morning on both Saturday and Sunday, and then switch to the other side for the afternoon. This way, each team competes as the defense and as the plaintiff or prosecution twice. This means the maximum number of ballots a team can take is eight, if they win both ballots in all four rounds of trial.
There is also a specific ranking system for witnesses and attorneys. At the bottom of their ballots, there is a section for judges to rank the top five witnesses and attorneys in the round. These rankings are each associated with a point system, with the maximum being a perfect score of 20 ranks. There are individual awards for high-ranking witnesses and attorneys at every competition, usually starting around the 17-rank mark.
The Pace Mock Trial Season Ahead
The basic timeline of Pace Mock Trial’s season includes three invitationals, where teams can compete against other schools in the traditional Mock Trial setting and try to polish their theories to see what works and what doesn’t. The real competition starts in the spring, with Regionals. Usually, a team will need to take at least five or six ballots to make it out of Regionals and on to Open Round Championships (ORCs). From all the ORCs, only a total of forty-two teams nationwide are chosen to compete at Nationals, after which one winner is named.
In order to prepare for competitions, Pace Mock Trial holds practice for all of its team members three times a week, with each practice lasting three hours or more. In my personal experience, while these practices certainly take up time, they are well worth the effort. They also inspire a closeness among team members, and help all of us feel more connected with one another.
On average, in the past, the team has a history of taking two or three ballots at the first invitational, taking more and more ballots throughout the season, until we finally manage to take five or so at Regionals. The team has also had several competitors earn individual witness or attorney rank awards, but not until the second or third invitational of the season. The team is normally small enough that several members compete on both the plaintiff or prosecution and the defense, requiring them to learn double the content.
Pace Mock Trial has always been something of an underdog compared to other nearby schools like NYU, Columbia, and Yale—all larger schools, with greater funding, student populations to draw from, and faculty leadership compared to Pace’s admittedly smaller program. Pace Mock Trial is entirely student-run and student-led, often with just enough competitors to run one team of twelve, with one coach (Logan Connelly, an alumni of Pace and Pace Mock Trial, who has been coaching since his graduation in 2023). This year, we are hoping to continue our positive momentum, given our phenomenal start to the season, and hopefully make Pace Mock Trial history by making it all the way to Nationals in the spring.
“There’s definitely still a lot to learn and room for us to grow overall, but I think we have an incredibly dedicated and talented team, and I’m really proud of what we’ve accomplished so far.” Shweiki commented, looking ahead to the future of Pace Mock Trial’s 2026–2027 season. He and I are in agreement, as executive board members and returning competitors, that we hope to see Pace University Mock Trial’s hard work and effort continue to pay off.
If you want to follow along with our season, or are interested in getting involved next year, check out the